Two Earl Greys, One Choice
Earl Grey is one of the most recognisable black tea blends, thanks to its distinctive bergamot aroma. But if you browse the blends at Coffee-Direct.co.uk, you will also find Earl Grey Citrus Tea – a variation that adds lemon and orange teas to the classic formula. Both come from the same loose-leaf family, but they deliver noticeably different cups. This comparison looks at what each blend contains, how they taste, and which one fits your drinking habits.
What the Catalog Confirms About Each Tea
- Earl Grey Tea: Offering up wonderful, fresh flavours of bergamot, Earl Grey is a delightful large leaf tea that, while typically served as a black tea, is just as enjoyable when served with milk. With flavours derived from oil extracted from the rind of the fragrant bergamot orange. This confirms the classic blend uses Ceylon black tea scented with bergamot oil – no added citrus pieces. It is a straightforward, aromatic black tea that takes milk well.

Earl Grey Tea - Earl Grey Citrus Tea: Made from a delightful blend of Earl Grey tea, with leaves scented with oil from the rind of the bergamot orange fruit, as well as lemon and orange teas, this brings together aromatic bergamot, delightful hints of orange, and clean lemon flavours for a light and highly satisfying tea. The citrus version keeps the bergamot base but adds actual lemon and orange teas, creating a brighter, tangier profile. The catalog describes it as 'light' – a clue that it may not take milk as naturally as the classic.

Earl Grey Citrus Tea
Flavour and Serving Side by Side
The classic Earl Grey is a large leaf black tea with bergamot oil – floral, slightly spicy, and robust enough to stand up to milk. The catalog notes it is 'just as enjoyable when served with milk,' which tells you it is a traditional British-style cup.
Earl Grey Citrus adds lemon and orange teas to the bergamot base. The catalog describes the result as 'light and highly satisfying,' with 'clean lemon flavours' and 'hints of orange.' This is a tea meant to be enjoyed on its own or as an iced tea during warmer weather – the catalog specifically suggests serving it as 'a refreshing iced tea.'
- Classic Earl Grey: Bergamot-forward, suitable with or without milk. A versatile daily black tea.
- Earl Grey Citrus: Bright, tangy, and lighter in body. Best served black or iced. The citrus notes may clash with milk.
Ingredients and Allergen Notes
Both teas share the same allergen disclaimer: the factory handles nuts, milk, and soy ingredients, and the specific ingredient list should be checked on the package. The classic Earl Grey lists 'Ceylon Black Tea, Bergamot Oil' as its components. The citrus version lists 'Earl Grey Tea, Lemon Tea, Orange Tea.' Neither tea contains added citrus fruit pieces in the classic – the citrus version uses additional tea leaves flavoured with lemon and orange.
If you have a sensitivity to citrus oils or added flavourings, the classic Earl Grey is the simpler choice. If you enjoy a fruitier cup without artificial additives, the citrus blend offers a natural citrus twist through additional tea types.
Which One Should You Choose?
Pick the classic Earl Grey if you want a traditional bergamot black tea that works with milk, suits breakfast or afternoon tea, and has a familiar, aromatic profile. It is a safe, versatile choice for everyday drinking.
Choose Earl Grey Citrus if you prefer a lighter, tangier cup, enjoy iced tea, or want a bergamot base with a citrus kick. It is a good option for warmer months or when you want a tea that feels less heavy. Both are available in the same size options (125g to 2.5kg), so you can match the bag to your drinking pace.



